Our Story

Learn how our team of investors helps owners succeed.

The Investor's Advantage

MRA Property Management was founded in 2021 and operates as a subsidiary of Tampa, FL based MRA Capital Partners, a boutique real estate investment firm with over 600 units and $100m + in direct real estate investment experience. We know firsthand how important strong, reliable, and cost-effective management is to the bottom line and total return of a real estate investment. We treat your property as if it was ours.

Architects discussing building model on table.

Financial Foresight

We focus on maximizing your rental income and minimizing vacancies through careful planning and market analysis.

Property Upkeep

We maintain properties with regular inspections and prompt repairs, protecting their long-term value.

Seamless Management

We handle all tenant relations and administrative tasks, making ownership hassle-free.

Our Proactive Approach

We believe in a hands-on method to property management. Our strategies are built to be proactive, not reactive, ensuring your rental properties are always performing at their best.

Meet Our Team

68ac7ef0683e3_Adam Headshot 1

Paul Plemenos

CEO-Managing Partner

Under Paul’s leadership, MRA Property Management has grown from a single asset management company to a robust full-service firm with in-house leasing, management, accounting and maintenance delivering superior value to property owners and residents across the Tampa Bay area. Paul’s “people before profit” mindset has led the firm to 3x growth under his watch.

In addition to being MRA Property Management's CEO and Managing Partner, Paul is also a Partner and an investment committee member of MRA Capital Partners and serves as the Director of Wealth Management at MRA Advisory Group since July of 2015.

From 2010–2015 he was a Financial Advisor and Vice President at Merrill Lynch; from 2003-2010, Financial Advisor and First Vice President at Wells Fargo Advisors and from 1997-2003, Financial Advisor and Associate Vice President at Morgan Stanley.

He holds the following registrations: FINRA 7, 63, 65, 31. He earned a BS in Environmental and Business Economics from Rutgers University, NJ in 1991. His interests include managing a Pro-Am auto racing team who's main purpose is to raise money for the Goryeb Children's Hospital.

Read More
68ac7ef0683e3_Adam-Headshot-2-2048x1787 1

Colbey Amspaugh

Director of Property Management and Business Development

With over a decade of experience in property management, Colbey Amspaugh has built her career around helping property owners and investors achieve peace of mind and consistent returns. As a licensed Real Estate Broker in the state of Florida, Colbey combines in-depth industry knowledge with a results-driven approach to managing residential and investment properties.

Colbey is an active member of the National Association of Residential Property Managers (NARPM) and the Florida Real Estate Association, staying at the forefront of industry best practices and evolving market trends. Her expertise in communication, client relations, and operational management allows her to build strong relationships while delivering efficient, transparent, and reliable service.

Colbey’s investor-minded perspective sets her apart—she understands the challenges of ownership firsthand and approaches every property as if it were her own. Dedicated to professionalism, integrity, and client success, Colbey continues to raise the standard of property management for the owners and communities she serves.

Read More
68ac7ef0683e3_Adam Headshot 2

Jim Gualtieri

Director of Operations

With over 30 years of experience in Finance and Accounting, Jim brings a wealth of expertise and insight to the world of property investment. A proud graduate of Michigan State University, he holds a Bachelor's degree in Finance and has built a career rooted in precision, integrity, and results-driven service.

Throughout his career, Jim has consistently demonstrated an unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction, ensuring that every client receives personalized attention and strategic guidance tailored to their investment goals. Whether navigating complex financial landscapes or streamlining accounting operations, Jim combines deep industry knowledge with a hands-on approach to make your property investment goals a reality.

Read More
Screenshot 2025-09-17 104901

Justin Amspaugh

Director of Property Maintenance and Construction Mangement

With over a decade of hands-on experience in property maintenance and renovation, Justin Amspaugh brings a comprehensive skill set to every project—from routine upkeep to full-scale property transformations. He has partnered with both property management firms and private homeowners, consistently delivering top-tier results while maintaining cost-effective solutions.
Justin’s expertise spans:
  • Full unit renovations and project oversight
  • Team and subcontractor supervision
  • Advanced HVAC systems knowledge
  • Flooring and cabinetry installation
  • Landscaping enhancements and exterior upgrades
Driven by a commitment to quality craftsmanship, budget-conscious planning, and reliable service, Justin ensures every property he touches is maintained and improved to the highest standards.
Read More
4

Adam Anderson

Partner

Adam is a founding partner of MRA Property Management and has more than 25 years of real estate investing and asset management experience. He is the founder, CEO and Managing Partner of MRA Capital Partners, a boutique real estate investment company with over $100m of value-add and real estate development experience. Under Adam’s leadership, the firm grew from zero to 600+ units across the east coast.

Prior to launching MRA Capital Partners, Adam was a Managing Partner and co-founder of MRA Advisory Group, a registered investment advisor with over $300m of assets under management and offices in Tampa, FL and Parsippany, NJ where he is currently the Director of Alternative Investments.

Adam’s robust experience with value-add real estate investing and construction management began during his time with one of the nation’s top home builders, Pulte Homes where he completed the development of large single-family developments. He received a BS in Finance and a BS in Real Estate in 2005 from The Florida State University, Tallahassee FL.

Read More
875cddaa-2ec3-48ba-99fb-aea7c030c3fb

Chris Sprowls, Esq

Partner

Mr. Sprowls is the Managing Partner of Rooker Ward Partners, a business consulting and development firm with a strategic focus on Florida. He is also Of Counsel to the national law firm of Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney. He served as Speaker of the Florida House of Representatives from 2020-2022 and represented North Pinellas County in the Florida House. Mr. Sprowls attended the University of South Florida, and then Stetson University College of Law, receiving his Juris Doctor in 2009. He served as a gang and homicide prosecutor in Tampa Bay for seven years and was the host of the Read, White and Blue Podcast streaming on Apple. He now lives in Palm Harbor with his wife Shannon and their two sons.

Read More

Partner With Confidence

Our extensive experience in the real estate market, coupled with our commitment to clear communication, provides a partnership you can trust. We are dedicated to providing exceptional service that makes a real difference to your bottom line.

Let's Get Started